Best Italian Restaurant in Holladay, Salt Lake County, UT

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Salt Lake City, UT at 4536 Highland Dr

Traditional Italian Cuisine Crafted Fresh Daily, Featuring Award-Winning Recipes, Tableside Classics, And A Warm Full-Service Dining Experience

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Sicilia Mia

Award-Winning Italian in Salt Lake City. Sicilia Mia is a X5 Best of State Italian restaurant in the heart of Holladay, Utah. Our family kitchen prepares fresh pasta daily and serves full-service Italian dining in a warm, polished setting. Known for tableside carbonara and classic Sicilian recipes with a modern touch, we welcome locals, visitors, couples, and families looking for a refined yet relaxed meal. Dine in and enjoy Italian cooking done with care, consistency, and pride.

Explore Sicilia Mia

Celebrate Together, Italian Style

From large family gatherings to full restaurant buyouts, Sicilia Mia is ready to host your next special occasion. Our team can help plan group dining, private parties, and off-site catering with flexible options for events of all sizes. Share your details, and a team member will reach out to help bring your get-together together with ease and care.

Plan Your Party

Save Your Table Today

Sicilia Mia is a lively, best of Salt Lake City voted trattoria offering elevated Italian dining in Holladay. Reservations are recommended, especially for evenings and weekends. We offer online booking through OpenTable to help you secure a great table with ease. Plan ahead and enjoy one of Utah’s most awarded Italian dining experiences.

Book a Reservation

Italian, Just a Click Away

Enjoy Sicilia Mia from the comfort of home with easy online ordering for takeout or delivery. Our full menu is available online, making it simple to enjoy your favorite Italian dishes whenever it fits your day. Don’t feel like cooking today? We got you covered – order now! Order your favorite dishes in seconds!

Order Now

Fresh Pasta, Italian Classics

Our menu features Italian favorites made fresh each day, including our award-winning tableside carbonara, house pasta, and traditional Sicilian dishes. Each plate is prepared with balanced ingredients and time-tested methods that highlight comfort and quality. Whether you’re here for lunch or dinner, our menu is built for dependable meals that keep guests coming back again and again.

View the Menu

Italian Catering Made Simple

Did you know we do catering? Sicilia Mia offers Italian catering for birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events, and wedding festivities. Whether your event is big or small, we provide well-prepared dishes and smooth coordination to make hosting easier. Let our team handle the food so you can focus on your guests and the moment.

Request Catering

What our guests are saying

A fantastic Italian restaurant with authentic flavors and a cozy ambiance. The pasta is fresh, the sauces are rich, and the pizza has the perfect crispy crust. Excellent service and a great wine selection complete the experience. Highly recommend for a true taste of Italy!

Nisa C.

We’ve been going to Sicilia Mia and Antica for years, almost weekly, the food, staff and atmosphere is top notch!! We are big foodies and this is our go to, whether we are in the mood for seafood, a great steak, pasta, pizza or all 4 this place hit the spot every single time! Truly a gem like none other, we love Claudio!! He makes the experience a 10 star!!

Enisa K.

Great spot for a special occasion. Came with a big party of 12 (had reservations) and they killed every step of the dinner. Got the carbonara and it was amazing! Next time I’ll get the steak for sure. Kaitlyn our server was on point!